Friday, December 4, 2015

The birth of Joan



Friday evening as Davey and I lay with Sophia to help her fall asleep for the night I noticed some contractions, but didn’t think much of them. I thought I was just tired and they’d go away after I fell asleep. Sophia and I had had a very busy, very happy day with Esther and her kids; we spent the morning at the ranch playing and in the afternoon we baked a quadruple batch of pumpkin muffins, roasted a turkey, cleaned the house, and even though she had repeatedly mother-hen’ed me to “sit down and put your feet up!”, I hadn’t.

After Sophia fell asleep I mentioned the contractions to Davey but told him they were probably just fatigue contractions and would go away with rest and hydration. He went out to read on the computer and about an hour later around 9:30 I came out of our bedroom to tell him the contractions were pretty consistent and this just might be real labor. He said okay and returned his attention to the online New York Times. I wasn’t convinced it was real either. I’d been expecting to go into labor for so long and had said too often, “I bet today is the day!” Since my anticipation was always for naught, I had kind of quit expecting it to happen.

But, I called Billye anyway and told her I was having fairly consistent contractions but that they weren’t intense at all and yada yada. We decided I would go back to bed and call her later if it looked like the contractions were sticking around.

When I couldn’t fall asleep, I got out of bed, kicked Davey off the computer and good naturedly bossed him around for a while. Might as well prepare in case this was really it! One thing that must be captured for all of posterity is that during this time, Davey seriously pointed out this “one spot” on his shoulders that was killing him and repeatedly requested me to massage it for him. I kept laughing and declining without remorse, “Dude, I’m probably in labor and you want me to massage you?”

Of all the “prepare for labor” to-do list items, one thing I was adamant he had to do first. I had been asking him for weeks (maybe months?) to make me a stone necklace to wear during the birth. I wore his homemade stone pendant during Sophia’s labor and I wanted a new one to wear for this baby. My plan was to gift the necklaces to my children someday when they were having their first babies so that they (or their wives) could wear it during the labors of their own children. And so he headed off to the back of the house and made me and our new baby a stone pendant and cordage necklace to wear.

We called Matt Howard and he headed over to help Davey give me a blessing in preparation for the birth. (Which cracks me up, because we always forget that blessings of comfort (not healing) only need one person.) As we chit chatted with Matt it all felt kind of surreal, thinking that I was about to do something very, very difficult, but here we were just chatting about this and that. I don’t remember many specifics of what Davey said during the blessing, but I remember feeling somehow both peaceful and excited. I remember he spoke of God’s love for me, and that during this challenging experience I would grow to know God in the depths of my soul.

After Matt left, I got in the tub for the first time but got out soon after because honestly the contractions just weren’t intense and I felt like being up and about. I looked over to see Davey sitting in our rocker looking exhausted, and since it looked like this baby might be a long time coming, I told him he could go to bed if he wanted. He went straight to bed and fell fast asleep the second his head hit the pillow. As normal.

Of course I didn’t though, I wandered around the house in my sports bra and skirt - cleaning, brewing pregnancy tea, eating pumpkin muffins and turkey, and getting all the details in place - all the while rubbing my belly and smiling.
I was starting to believe this was really it and I was getting more and more excited. The house was dark and silent, and as I’d moan softly to myself through the contractions I felt motherly, calm and happy. Each time I’d walk past Davey’s sleeping form I’d smile and feel so benevolent and loving toward him. “Sleep well, my dear husband, soon you’ll be holding my hand and wiping my brow as I push out our new baby!”

The contractions were sometimes intense, sometimes barely noticeable. For a while they’d be every five minutes or so and then they’d spread out longer. Honestly I didn’t keep track of them too carefully, it was annoying to try to time them – I enjoyed working through them much more when I wasn’t staring at a clock. When I’d feel the tightening coming sometimes I’d lean over the table and sway my hips while moaning, or I really liked walking through them – that was a strange but good sensation, they felt very productive when I’d walk through them. I also liked to stand in front of the bathroom mirror so I could watch as my belly would get incredibly tight and unreal looking. I’d never seen such a thing – it was like all that was left of me was skin and baby. I couldn’t get enough of it - it made my jaw drop every time. I felt very happy and close to this new little spirit that was preparing to join our family.

When my bowels started loosening right on up, I decided I better call Billye. Maybe the uncomfortable diarrhea sensation kicked me out of my dream-like happy labor state. Honestly, I kind of forgot about needing to call her for a while there. It was about 1 AM when I called her and updated her, finishing with, “I’m feeling great, some contractions are intense, some aren’t, but I think if my water broke things might progress faster.” She practically jumped through the phone, I swear, “Oh my goodness Rachel, you should have called me earlier! I may not get there in time, but if I don’t - just know that everything will be okay. I’m throwing my contacts in and jumping in the car! I’ll be there as soon as I can, just tell Davey to get ready, ‘cause he may have to catch this baby!”
“Oh wow… well…maybe I should wake him up then???”

I had a little adrenaline rush during that conversation, that’s for sure. But I couldn’t imagine I was that close to delivering this baby, I mean everything felt so manageable and light. The grueling, intense part of labor that I knew would come eventually still seemed miles away. But I went in and woke up Davey and told him jokingly “You may need to catch this baby, so up and at ‘em!”. We started calling everyone and I got in the tub, hoping that it would slow down labor in case things did get intense too quick for the hour and a half drive Billye had ahead of her.

When Billye and Misti arrived little before 3 AM, I was still speaking easily and stretching and moving around the tub. They listened to the baby, set up all their gear, and then finally were ready to check my dilation. I was just itching to know if I was crying wolf like I had been for the last month, or if this was really happening. Honestly I wouldn’t have been surprised if I was still at a two.

I asked if it’d be easier to check me on the bed instead of the tub and since that was an affirmative I jumped out of the tub and headed to Sophia’s empty bed (she was asleep on her toddler mattress in our bedroom). I had to stop along the way to work through a contraction and it felt longer and stronger than any other I’d had. “Very exciting”, I said as soon as it passed.

After Billye listened to the heart rate again, I was very surprised and a bit concerned to see Misti putting the gloves on and preparing to check me. She had only attended maybe three of my prenatal visits and I knew she was at the beginning of the “hands on” part of her midwifery training. I had assumed she would only be observing during my labor since that is all she had done during the prenatal visits as well. It also surprised me that they didn’t ask, “Is it ok if Misti checks you instead?” But I brushed my concerns aside with a little inward pep talk of, “for the good of midwifery, Rachel!” and, “it’s ok to let her practice on you, everything is so chill and easy right now!”

And it was, it went fine and she deemed my dilation between a 7.5 and an 8. They were immediately gushing compliments – ooing and aweing my greatness and telling me how amazing I was doing. It was strange because I knew they were just doing their best at being encouraging. But I felt waves of discomfort. I felt all of a sudden very…self-aware. Like I felt this pressure to do fantastic, to be the strong wonder woman that everyone was telling me I was. I didn’t want to think about how amazing or strong or great I was or wasn't. I think part of the reason things were going so smoothly was because I hadn’t had to worry about how I was doing – I was just doing it. If that makes sense. Inside, I was wishing I was back alone with just the baby and I working together with Davey sleeping by our side.

I got back in the tub and tried to get out of my head. I was glad that the only light in the room was a tiny lamp in the corner - the darkness helped me feel safer. And things kept going well, the contractions were getting stronger and I was losing my sense of time and awareness. I no longer opened my eyes between contractions.


After a while (the notes say it was about 40 minutes after Misti checked me) I felt that familiar “this is too much” feeling starting to come at the height of each contraction. My moans were turning more wail-like and I remember calling out, “Check me Billye, check me – tell me if it feels like this because I could be pushing!” I had told her during prenatal visits that I had never felt the urge to start pushing with Sophia, but that once I had started pushing it had been my absolute favorite part of labor so it was very important to me that she help me figure out the very earliest that I could start.

I opened my eyes briefly and saw Misti, not Billye, leaning over the tub putting on gloves in preparation to check how dilated I was. “No, no, no.” was what I felt but I just shut my eyes and tried to breathe deep.
And then I felt pain like I can’t describe. Like my head was exploding. Like she was down there ripping my cervix open with a chain saw. Sorry for the graphic description, but there really is no way to describe the horrendousness of that feeling. I finally yelled, “Get out, get out, get out!” and then a desperate half sob, “What am I? Am I complete? Can I push?” And no answer came, just some mumbles of “Um…well...I’m not sure.” And I had lost it. My whole body was shaking and I was crying uncontrollably. I was hyperventilating, and I literally couldn't see straight.

Looking back on it I already feel compassion for Misti, I’m sure she was nervous and trying her absolute best in what I’m guessing was an awkward and unfamiliar angle for her in the birth tub. But at the tim,e although I was nowhere near able to process it into words, I was completely overwhelmed with anger and pain and a deep, deep sense of betrayal. This was an incredibly vulnerable moment and I had trusted Billye to be there when I needed her competence and experience and most. And really, I was upset at myself that I hadn't just said "No thank you" when I didn't feel comfortable with Misti in the first place. Billye was trying to tell me to “breathe”, or something to try and calm me I’m sure. I yelled, “Don’t talk to me!” and then turned toward Davey and begged him to hold me.
He held me tight with my face buried in his shoulder while I sobbed and shook and tried to breathe again. “Talk to me, tell me something”, I cried in his ear. And honestly I have no recollection of what he actually said, only feeling like I was holding on to him for dear life, and feeling a small sense of reprieve from the glare of everything. Over the next few minutes of hiding in his arms I slowly felt the intensity of the exploding in my head quiet and my breathing slow down. I asked for a tissue and tried to deal with the mass quantities of snot that was keeping me from breathing normally.

And then, my water broke. Billye said, “Why don’t you try pushing.” And she got no response from me because there was no other option - once that water broke my body was pushing without me. I was still facing the side of the tub with my arms around Davey and that felt terrible while pushing so I begged him help move me move quickly to a more squat, facing out position, with him supporting me under my arms.
It was strange pushing, so unlike with Sophia. I felt like I never got a break, and like I wasn’t working together with my body, no, instead my body was on a train ride that was screaming down the tracks at 100 miles an hour. I was quiet now, just low moans and deep breathing, no wailing or hyperventilating, but it wasn’t how it should be – that I could tell.

I had planned for Sophia to be there for the end of pushing and the birth. I remember feeling the baby moving down so much with each push and knowing it was coming fast, so I called out for Nathalie to bring Sophia in much sooner than I would have thought. She sat on Nathalie's lap on the rocking chair near the side of the tub. It was still impossible to open my eyes, but occasionally I would hear Sophia yawn loudly. I knew I would be smiling about that soon.

I only pushed for 16 minutes total and at 4:54 AM she was here. Misti pulled her up from the water to my chest and I held her and thanked God over and over that she was here.
We actually didn’t know what sex she was for a couple minutes at least, I just held my baby and felt the peace and the warmth push the panic, desperate feeling out of my heart.
Finally I remembered, and peeked between her legs, “She’s a girl, Davey! She’s a girl!”
He hung over my shoulder and hugged us and held her little hand.
As she slowly pinked up, we brought Sophia over and she sat on Davey’s lap while we loved on her, and the midwives did their checks.
After the cord stopped pulsing Sophia jumped up and down with excitement that she could help cut it. Davey helped her hands hold the scissors and she hasn't stopped talking about it yet.
“I thought it was a boy!” I remember her saying at some point. She also asked when the baby would start crawling.
My placenta was slower to come, even when I had already put her to my breast, so they had me give the baby to Davey and I tried moving around and different positions to help it speed up.
They gave me some bitter tasting herb liquid to drink that was supposed to help. About half an hour after she was born, Billye had Misti pull gently on the cord and the placenta finally came.

The midwife's helped me walk slowly to my bed, all the while assuring me that I probably wouldn’t have a tear since I had “just breathed that baby right out.” I remember lifting an eyebrow at that since it certainly had felt much different than then that to me. And when they checked me, I was right – there was what they described as a small tear and Billye felt it needed stitching. I had learned my lesson and very clearly told them that I wanted Billye to do it.

First though, they had Davey bring the baby in and let her latch and let me revel in her sweetness with Davey.
Heather, our birth photographer hadn’t arrived until after the placenta was already out. Poor woman ran out of gas and got lost. But I was so happy to see her taking lots of photos now. Even though she was friendly and unobtrusive, Sophia still gave her dirty looks and resisted any family photos with her in it. That’s our Sophia, I smiled and didn’t even care.
Misti gave the baby her newborn check while we all sat close and watched on. She weighed 7 lbs 4 oz and handled the checks without crying.





I ate a few bites of a grilled cheese sandwich that Jani made me, and then we had some time alone as a family to have a prayer with just us and Sophia. Then we sent Sophia out to make hot cocoa with Nathalie, and Davey held the baby in the other room while I got prepped for the stitches.


And here is where all the terrible adjectives want to come out again. I cannot believe how badly those stitches hurt. They assured me they had both sprayed a numbing agent and given me a numbing shot, but I tell you what I felt every single thing. I sobbed and sobbed and said “just get it over with” when they apologized that it shouldn’t be hurting. My face was a swollen mess and I felt like I was barely hanging on emotionally by the time they brought the baby back to me. My back had also gone into a terrible spasm while I tried to walk to the bathroom. It was like no other back pain I’d ever felt. Every single breath was…pain and more pain. I swallowed the max dosage of ibuprofen and cried inside.




I wanted to kiss the ground she walked on when Nathalie offered to take Sophia with her to her house. Sophia was already acting needy and on edge, and I felt a very heavy weight on my shoulders. All I wanted was to put my sweet baby to my breast and sleep for the next 20 hours.

This is what I wrote a couple weeks after the birth.

December 16th, 2010

The birth of this second daughter of mine was so different from the first. Most of the labor was much, much easier. For reasons that I'll have to write more about later, the end of it was much, much harder. I feel like I entered The World of Pain and Anguish during the last part of her birth and for the first couple days after she entered the world. This photo is hard for me to look at; a picture really is worth a thousand words.

The last stage of labor with Sophia was incredibly exhilarating. Wonderful. Satisfying. Fulfilling. And that feeling continued in full force for the first couple days after her birth.

I expected to find that zen, in-the-zone, time stops, "peace-in-the-midst-of-difficulty" that I felt with such intensity during the pushing stage of Sophia's labor. I expected to feel that most dramatic example of how God can consecrate any experience if I just give up my attempts to do it by myself.

But guess what? I didn't. And it sucked. Big time. I think I'd say I was more self-focused and miserable than I've ever been.

And I can't quite believe I'm saying this, but I'm already starting to appreciate the differences and she's only twelve days old. I thought it would take longer (much, much longer) but it's happening already - probably because this little gal is melting my heart.

In my day to day life, I'm always trying to figure out how to love where I'm at. How to feel grateful and peaceful in the midst of every experience God has allowed to cross my path, even the hard ones - whether the monotonous kind of hard or the dramatic kind of hard. I'm always upset at myself when I know I'm missing out on feeling God's grace because I'm too stubborn to receive it.

And when I saw these photos that were taken of the sunrise that came an hour after Joan entered this world, I realized what this labor, birth, and recovery has taught me.

If Sophia's birth taught me what it was like to lose myself in the service of another, then Joan's birth taught me that it's okay when I don't.

The sun will always rise.


Saturday, September 19, 2015

Parenting with Confidence: a philosophy toward living 18 years of gratitude instead of rage and self-hatred


It's 1:00 PM on Saturday afternoon and she's knitting a pair of mittens with tinker toy sticks in her pajamas on our porch that is currently unwalkable (due to her craft supplies/toys strewn all over it). 


When she was a baby/toddler I remember telling people, "I still agree with all the advice I gave parents for all those years (while working for a child development/parent support organization), it's just that now I know how hard it is to actually do all those things I suggested.

These days I can't hardly believe "those" days were real. Like, they're surreal. I mean, was I SERIOUS? And the things is, I WAS. I was serious, and it's...ludicrous in a way that is hard to believe was my reality. Six years later and three kids under my belt and all I can say I know about raising kids is that it's a wild ride and that once you're on, your're on. That's it. That's all I know, dear children: I'm your mom and I won't leave you.

Last week in therapy I was actually doing an "empty chair" exercise where I stumbled upon that realization in a way that clicked for me. I was supposed to pretend Sophia was sitting in the empty chair and express to her her how I feel without worrying if it's developmentally appropriate/helpful, and that's where I sobbed out this: 
"I don't know what to do to help you, but I will never leave you."

And then I switched chairs, wiped my eyes, and pretended to be her responding to me and "she" said to me:

"Good! I hate it when you act like you know everything." And also, "What the hell, you're my mom, you're supposed to know everything. Hmph!"
And my therapist laughed and laughed.

I've been thinking about how unexpected his response was and also about how much I liked it. And how if I had to sum up my child rearing philosophy, maybe it would be all of that combined.
"Dear offspring, 
I don't know what's best, but I know I'll never leave you. And confidence in those two things means I get to cry and laugh a lot while I raise you, and that makes for a very rich life. So, thanks!"

Monday, September 14, 2015

Modesty is about revealing our dignity

I saved a post under my "to read later" list because I liked the tag line from it: "Modesty isn't about hiding ourselves. It's about revealing our dignity." It sounded like a great way to talk about modesty with my girls because it makes sense to explain that there are as many different ways a person could reveal their dignity as there are cultures and individuals in the world.

And then I read the actual article and it pissed me off.

What my daughters will be taught, and how I try to live my own life:

 "What others think of you is none of your business. Dress however helps your life feel full and rich and dignified and then don't give it another thought. Which by the way is the most "modest" way to treat those around you, because you know what is super, super IMmodest? Being critical of how someone else chooses to clothe their body. Yeah. That's a really UNdignified thing to do. So focus on you and realize that how you dress will change over time as you change, and as your relationship to your culture changes, but seriously - do not lose sleep over anyone who tries to make how you choose to cover your body THEIR business. Unless they're lobbying to change their nation's laws on dress, I guess. Then fine - THAT is a reasonable place to respond to them if you have the time, energy and interest."

Which made me laugh by the time I got to the end of that. So freaking ridiculous I can't even believe I'm still writing about it.

But you know why I am? Cause I saw this in my newsfeed the other day.


Leave the girls alone, self-righteous jerk faces. Just support them and love them and care about them and trust them or leave them ALONE. And now I'm sitting here wondering why I didn't include myself in that. My therapist always makes me re-word stuff like this too. So here is what I really want to say:

 "Leave US alone, self-righteous jerk faces. Just support us and love us and care about us and trust us or leave us ALONE."

And now i'll go take my own advice and move on with making choices that help me live a full, rich, dignified life. Whew...:p














Sunday, September 6, 2015

nothing else left to impart


I'm crying my way through cleaning my house and thinking that if God is real then this is how I feel about him.



The only reason why I continue at all
Faith in reason, I wasted my life playing dumb
Signs and wonders: sea lion caves in the dark
Blind faith, God’s grace, nothing else left to impart

Do I care if I survive this, bury the dead where they’re found
In a veil of great surprises; hold to my head till I drown
Should I tear my eyes out now, before I see too much?
Should I tear my arms out now, I wanna feel your touch

Should I tear my eyes out now?
Everything I see returns to you somehow
Should I tear my heart out now?
Everything I feel returns to you somehow

Sunday, August 30, 2015

Thank you, Oliver Sacks


From the piece I read in February http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/19/opinion/oliver-sacks-on-learning-he-has-terminal-cancer.html by Oliver Sacks after he found out he was terminally ill:

"And yet, one line from Hume’s essay strikes me as especially true: “It is difficult,” he wrote, “to be more detached from life than I am at present.”

Over the last few days, I have been able to see my life as from a great altitude, as a sort of landscape, and with a deepening sense of the connection of all its parts. This does not mean I am finished with life.

On the contrary, I feel intensely alive, and I want and hope in the time that remains to deepen my friendships, to say farewell to those I love, to write more, to travel if I have the strength, to achieve new levels of understanding and insight.

This will involve audacity, clarity and plain speaking; trying to straighten my accounts with the world. But there will be time, too, for some fun (and even some silliness, as well).

I feel a sudden clear focus and perspective. There is no time for anything inessential. I must focus on myself, my work and my friends. I shall no longer look at “NewsHour” every night. I shall no longer pay any attention to politics or arguments about global warming.

This is not indifference but detachment — I still care deeply about the Middle East, about global warming, about growing inequality, but these are no longer my business; they belong to the future. I rejoice when I meet gifted young people — even the one who biopsied and diagnosed my metastases. I feel the future is in good hands."

I have thought a lot about that part about how detachment does not need to mean indifference, that it is still possible to care deeply about something without focusing on it. His words helped me see the serenity prayer in a new light and as such a clear definition of good boundaries, or maybe: "how to create a good life in three lines".

Grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change,
The courage to change the things I can,
And the wisdom to know the difference.
 
I'm not super great at it yet. But I'm getting better at it, and feeling gratitude for Oliver Sacks and writers like him for having a part in that. 

"Above all, I have been a sentient being, a thinking animal, on this beautiful planet, and that in itself has been an enormous privilege and adventure."


Saturday, August 22, 2015

I stood beneath an orange sky

I messaged this to my friend who studied Religion in college:

"This was simultaneously depressing and motivating to sit through.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKR-HydGohQ#t=438 

This is what I've appreciated about atheism: "Get busy, because this is your only chance. Inaction hurts worse than action. There is nothing left at the end, which means there is no failure, so no need to spend energy trying to avoid it." 

But I also feel pulled toward the comfort that faith brings: "Love is forever. The soul never dies, and cannot be separated from true love." 

Can't I have both? Dualism?"


She wrote back:

  • "Immanentist theologies basically do that same work. It's the notion that what matters about God is for the present, not the future. 
  • Christianity has transcendental (God is other than us, bigger than us and mostly beyond us) and immanentist (God is in the world or is the world, his power is here and now not in the future, and it's the power of love not force)"


I've sat on that a few days and this is what I think:


"Orange Sky"

Well I had a dream
I stood beneath an orange sky 
Yes I had a dream 
I stood beneath an orange sky 
With my brother standing by 
With my brother standing by 
I said, "Brother, you know you know 
It's a long road we've been walking on 
Brother, you know it is you know it is 
Such a long road we've been walking on." 

And I had a dream 
I stood beneath an orange sky 
With my sister standing by 
With my sister standing by 
I said, "Sister, here is what I know now 
Here is what I know now 
Goes like this.. 
In your love, my salvation lies 
In your love, my salvation lies 
In your love, my salvation lies 
In your love, in your love, in your love."

"But sister you know I'm so weary 
And you know, sister 
My heart's been broken 
Sometimes, sometimes 
My mind is too strong to carry on 
Too strong to carry on"

"When I am alone 
When I've thrown off the weight of this crazy stone 
When I've lost all care for the things I own 
That's when I miss you, that's when I miss you, that's when I miss you 
You who are my home 
You who are my home 
And here is what I know now 
Here is what I know now 
Goes like this.. 
In your love, my salvation lies 
In your love, my salvation lies 
In your love, my salvation lies 
In your love, my salvation lies 
In your love, my salvation lies 
In your love, my salvation lies 
In your love, my salvation lies 
In your love, in your love, in your love"

Well I had a dream 
I stood beneath an orange sky 
Yes I had a dream 
I stood beneath an orange sky 
With my brother and my sister standing by
With my brother and my sister standing by
With my brother and my sister standing by

Wednesday, July 29, 2015

Sophia today


From this morning:

Trying to convince Sophia that she should WANT to brush her teeth: 

Sophia: "Well fine, most of my teeth are baby teeth still anyway so if they turn black and fall out then FINE. I don't CARE. I'll just start brushing the grown up teeth when they come in that I DO care about." [stomps away]


Tonight I served my children a dinner of honey roasted cashews, dried banana slices, and chocolate milk. Sophia's response: "THIS IS THE BEST DAY OF MY LIFE! I mean, except for the last day of school...and...the last day of nature camp, but other than those best days, THIS is the BEST DAY OF MY LIFE."


Tonight tickling her back at bedtime: 

Sophia: Do you know what I want to be when I grow up? A pirate. Do they have real live pirates in real life, Mommy?

Me: Yes...there are real pirates but they aren't like on your kids shows. They are dangerous and they hurt people.

Sophia: Hmm....well...I'm just a little kid, there's lots of years 'till I grow up, maybe by the time I'm old enough to be a pirate then pirates will have become good.

Me: ...

Sophia: Mommy, will you tell me a story about when I was a baby?

Me: One time when we were in Brooklyn we were at a yard sale and you saw a stuffed animal and just hugged it and hugged it and wouldn't let it go, so Daddy and I bought it for you and you just LOVED that dog so much, it was so fluffy and cuddly and you carried it and played with it so much. I remember it made me so happy to watch you.

Sophia: What? I don't remember it! How old was I? 

Me: I think you were...one. 

Sophia: What happened to it, where is it now?

Me: You carried it so many places and used it so much that it got really dirty, so I had to throw it away.

Sophia: [quiet for awhile and then starts to sniffle and eventually sob on my shoulder] Why didn't you just give it away to a thrift store or something? Why didn't you give it to another child, why did you have to just throw it AWAY..." 

Me: [literally wiping her tears and kissing her forehead] It was just too old and worn out, sweetheart. But...do you know what happened to that dog after we couldn't use it as a toy anymore? It turned into dirt and became helpful and loved in a different, but just as important way - like helping a seed to sprout or a worm to have a home, or...a beetle to rest in. 

Sophia: sniffles until she falls asleep.


I just looked it up on our family blog and found this post from September 2008.

This is a stuffed dog we have named Perrito. We saw him at a stoop sale, gave him to Sophia to hold, she hugged him immediately and wouldn't let go. Cracked me and the seller of the "stuff" up. I talked Davey into letting us buy it (for a whole $3, I know I could've talked her down but what can I say I was feeling generous) and honestly it has been the best buy ever. She adores it. When she wakes up in the morning she runs to it making her version of a woof woof sound and she just hugs it and loves on, sitting on it, rubbing her face into it, kissing it with an open mouth. She also likes to bite his hair and shake her head around like an animal pulling some of his hair out. I discourage it of course, but whattya goin do? Really she just adores the heck out of that dog and I adore watching her adore it. :)



Saturday, June 20, 2015

On sexuality, victimhood and power

Ok so that title is much too ambitious for what I have the time/energy to offer today.

But here is what I do have.

I saw this video on FB and showed it to the girls and they loved it - watching it over and over. I loved it too.

 I am very careful how I talk about beauty to my daughters because I feel like the "re-define beauty" campaigns can be problematic in that it can be understood as valuing outward beauty over other characteristics. I wrote a bit about it here. I bring that up as just a small disclaimer that really has no other point to what I'm trying to talk about, just felt compelled to say that this guy that I'm about to quote saw the purpose of this video differently than I. I saw it as an invitation for women to lose themselves in the intensity of exercise or sports without caring what others thought. And that's what I used it as an example of in talking about it with my girls. When it said, "Of course I look hot", I interpreted that to be a little irony about how of course those involved in activities shown would be sweaty and hot in temperature and that a normal side-effect of getting lost in an activity that makes you feel powerful and alive is to not realize how you're looking. Wow. Sorry for that poorly written tangent, I should have just said, "When you read Julius Pringle's comment that is what I think too!" but there ya go, at least I made myself laugh writing this.

BUT, on to what I actually wanted to write about. First, this is a conversation thread under the youtube video above [disclaimer: some of the commenters use profanity]

Puddin Tame:
 Okay, I get that the whole idea of This Girl Can is to show women they needn't be self-conscious when they exercise and to try to demonstrate that they are beautiful when "sweating like a pig". But honestly, watching this video, I think it might be confirming some women’s worst suspicions about how they look working out.   Please help me understand. Why is it important to be beautiful? Is the only antidote to self-consciousness for women the assurance that they are beautiful? As a male, I know I look like shit at the gym. I’m so focused on my workout that I barely register that other people are there except when I’m waiting to use a piece of apparatus. If you told me, “someone was looking at you and saying you looked like a disgraceful fat shit at the gym today”, my honest response would be, “really? How fucking extraneous. It’s a gym, not a goddam beauty contest.”   Is empowerment really telling women they’re beautiful even when they’re sweating at the gym? Or might it be that being beautiful is extraneous at the gym? That perhaps you own your beauty and you don’t need to struggle and claw to keep it 24/7. That you can forget about it while you go do something good for your body that has nothing to do with how it looks while you’re doing it.


That's deep. The empowerment should come from letting go of one's vanity and being comfortable when doing it. Good one Puddin Tame. :)
· 4

Looking good is something everyone loves (I think), for women (and for men as well) is such a delicate topic because we are constantly under pressure: we should look flawless and fit and this and that, and that's bullshit. The goal is to be proud of ourselves and love our body because it is capable of many many things.  This video shows that doing sports should not only be about losing weight or getting fit, it should make everyone feel powerful and full of energy, relaxed and satisfied. This whole thing is about loving yourself more, and scream "Who the fuck cares how I look" to every person judging you or trying to kick you down :)
· 2

The point is not to care what other people think when they look at you.  It's not about how you look.  It's specifically about doing what you need to do without caring how you look. 


+Julius Pringle That's pretty much what I said in my post. That's not what I see portrayed in the video.





Maybe it's showing women that their attitude is sexier than the looks? That their self-empowered attitude,   in having their own motivation and initiative, and not shying away from the tough stuff, is sexy, regardless of the sweat or objective aesthetics of excercise (which I and many men find sexy anyway - why is this never emphasised to women?)?
· 6

+Monkeyherder3 "Maybe it's showing women that their attitude is sexier than the looks? That their self-empowered attitude,   in having their own motivation and initiative, and not shying away from the tough stuff, is sexy, regardless of the sweat or objective aesthetics of excercise (which I and many men find sexy anyway" That's the thing, though; women working out aren't sexy. My thesis is, they don't need to be. Sexiness is a situational attribute. Being sexy while you work out is irrelevant, and feeling you need to be is, in my opinion, a sign of insecurity. I see a woman working out like a beast and I'm inspired in exactly the way I'm inspired by a man working out like a beast, to make my own effort better. Her gender means nothing to me in that moment. "why is this never emphasised to women?)?" Their goddamned magazines are FULL of that empowering shit! Sandwiched between advertisements that feature skinny, airbrushed and unrealistically idealized depictions of women. And you can't blame men for that, because it wouldn't be that way if women didn't buy it.


+Puddin Tame Sure I see your point - they should not have to feel like they must be sexy all the time. I'm just saying that as a man, when I do see women being inspirational (in general, and including working out like beast) then I find that attractive, rather than the size of any particular body part.
·

+Puddin Tame Nothing in the video suggests the idea that 'women are still beautiful even when they are working out.' as the target demographic for this video, I don't receive that message at all. This video is showing normal, ordinary women of all ages, ethnicities, and abilities working out for the sake of their health and wellbeing. Which, for me, is exciting. It's literally the only other ad or campaign I have seen which embraces more than just white, slim, able bodied women working out. Look at any Nike shop anywhere or any gym anywhere, they're not just in magazines. Every media outlet that modern women consume often ignore women of colour, women who fall outside a size 8-12 (NZ sizing) in clothing, and especially women with disabilities and other health issues. That means there is a serious lack of diversity in the way women are portrayed in media which can lead to harmful effects on those groups of women. To a degree, men also are also subjected to this as well, but it pales in comparison to the way it is applied to women. Companies literally pay their bills off this ideal. There's nothing wrong with being, white, slim and able bodied, but it's really nice to see a realistic campaign that celebrates and gives a variety of women a platform to celebrate being healthy and celebrate working out without the underlying message of 'you must look like this particular type of women in order to be considered beautiful'. The opening line 'i jiggle, therefore i am" completely emphasises this. Many women are made to feel that the wobbly things that happen to your body while you exercise are meant to be hidden or be ashamed of. Which is untrue! This video is encouraging women to not be afraid to let themselves jiggle or their muffin top to hang out or their makeup to run, because it doesn't matter - which is the point you are talking about. And monkeyherder3, every comment you've made under this video keeps drawing back to the sexual appeal of women and how it relates to working out. The whole point of this video is to dispel the sexual connotations that are too often put unnecessarily on women in the media: e.g. fitness ads or campaigns.





+Natassja C "Many women are made to feel that the wobbly things that happen to your body while you exercise are meant to be hidden or be ashamed of." I must call bullshit on this general line of thinking. No one, male or female, is "made to feel" anything. Every individual is responsible for their feelings. Media content is designed to illicit feelings and that sucks, but if you and I can recognize targeted propaganda, anyone can. Saying women are "made to feel" things robs them of agency and reduces them to things which are acted upon, not the actors they rightfully are. You can't claim to be simultaneously strong and empowered, and vulnerable to being emotionally played.
· 3

Natassja
+Puddin Tame I'm just going to leave this here and let it speak for itself. Please watch it. https://vimeo.com/28066212
·

+Natassja C, Watched it. 10% legitimate complaints, 90% poor-me bullshit and misinformation. No one ever achieved liberation by whining to their exploiters to "please stop."
*****  
That last sentence has not left me since I read it. 
It is something that is hard to hear when you are legitimately a victim, but something that I am intent on learning and inviting my daughter's to learn - victimhood is real, and trying to do mental gymnastics to pretend that each of us aren't victims of others' mistreatment leads to it's own sorts of problems, BUT so does being fixated on trying to make others protect us when they can't or won't. 
Liberation comes from the satisfaction and fulfillment and meaning that comes from a life lived knowing we are doing all we can to protect ourselves from those who are hurting us. This applies generally to things like the world's sexism and oppression of women, and individually with our day to day lives and relationships.  
 Whatever else I agree or disagree with in that discussion, when that man wrote THIS: "No one ever achieved liberation by whining to their exploiters to "please stop."" it made me want to cross stitch and frame it in my girls' room. (Laughing again. But SRSLY.)
Okay these thoughts are totally not going to flow but again this is all I have time to throw out there and here it is. Those comments above about whether intense physical activities as shown are inherently sexual or not made me think of these parts from this interview found in it's entirety here. (I pulled out the parts that applied to sexuality as the discussion above brought up for me, but in the rest of the interview he had fascinating thoughts on depression and spirituality and religion as well.)
 For Thomas Moore, author of the bestseller Care of the Soul (HarperCollins), the great malady of our time is not any disease of the body but “the loss of soul.” Although difficult to define, he says, soul is best approached through imagination and makes itself known to us instinctively; it has to do with genuineness and depth rather than transcendence, and is tied to life in its particulars: good food, sex, conversation, true friendship.

A former psychotherapist, Moore believes that mental health is not just a matter of self-help or assertiveness training. Fundamentally, it involves accepting our human foibles and everyday problems without striving for perfection. He describes his approach to life as “polytheistic” and says we must honor all the gods of our humanity — the gods of war and jealousy, as well as the gods of love and wisdom. 

Moore was a Catholic monk for twelve years and has degrees in religion, theology, and musicology. His primary perspective, though, is that of archetypal psychology, a branch of psychology founded by Carl Jung and rooted not in science, but in myth and poetry, aesthetics and imagination. (Psychology and religion are, for Moore, inseparable.) The archetypal perspective, Moore contends, frees consciousness from the dry ground of literalism and seeks out the images that give rise to meaning. From this point of view, jealousy is not simply a negative feeling to eradicate, but an impulse deeply rooted in the soul. Like many of the emotions we label “negative,” it can be a “poison that heals.”
I met Moore fifteen years ago at a workshop he was leading for painters, photographers, writers, actors, and dancers wanting to explore the soul of their work. Years later, when Moore was planning a move to Massachusetts, where I live, he called me to inquire about how one gets a mortgage if one is a writer — i.e., a person without a steady income. 

Moore now lives with his wife, Hanley, and their two children on a mountaintop in eastern New Hampshire. I related my memories of our previous encounters to him recently as we sat across from each other at a large wooden table in his library, an elegant, high-ceilinged, oak-paneled room modeled, he said, on the principles of the Italian philosopher Marsilio Ficino.

Since becoming a best-selling author, Moore spends about ten weeks a year giving readings, lectures, and interviews, and has appeared on many radio and TV shows, including Oprah. His newfound fame and fortune seem to bemuse him, and he retains a quiet modesty and sincerity in person.

In addition to Care of the Soul, Moore has written Soul Mates, The Re-enchantment of Everyday Life, and The Soul of Sex (all HarperCollins). He is currently completing a book on religion and the soul.
Zeiger: What is the relationship between sexuality and soul?

Moore: Soul shows itself in many aspects of life, but particularly in sex. This is because, to use the Jungian term, sex is the “archetype” of life. In sex, we are dealing intimately with such essentials as self-expression, primal relatedness to one another, and the sense of being alive.

Zeiger: In The Soul of Sex, you talk about sex as something woven into the fabric of life and the senses; you say that nurturing one’s sexuality, in the broadest sense, means living through the senses.

Moore: I do think that everything in life is sexual. All the things we do, big or small, involve the ingredients of our sexuality: body, desire, fantasy, pleasure, frustration, sensuousness, relatedness. These ingredients can, of course, be considered singly and separately, but they may be better thought of as part of a larger whole: the erotic life. For ex­ample, I’m responding to your questions now partly from a rational standpoint, but also because I take pleasure from it. I find sensuous joy in making myself clear, in relating to the public, and in choosing my words carefully. In this sense, conversation is a type of sexual act. So our sexuality is not restricted to one corner of life, but suffuses the whole.

Let me give you another example: When I was a therapist, I’d say that well over half of my clients came to me to talk about sexual issues. Now, you could say that these people just had problems with sex, but I think it was deeper than that. As we work out our sexuality, we are working out our lives. Our sexuality is, in its most complete sense, connected to the way we live, to the sensuality, pleasure, and beauty in life. All the qualities you see in sex — beauty, body, intimacy, pleasure — form the sexual dimension of our everyday life.

Zeiger: Why are Americans so mixed up about sex?

Moore: One reason is that, despite the ever-present sexual images in our culture, we don’t live very sexual lives. We repress our deeper sexuality, and when you repress something, it becomes a monster in your face. Our society is oversexed precisely because we haven’t really grappled with sex and made it our own.
We believe we’re being moral when we repress our sex­­uality, and are perhaps even proud of having conquered our desires. In turn, we are quick to judge others for not being so in control. Recall the unbelievable hypocrisies on display during the Clinton impeachment trial. But if we could admit to our own desires and deal honestly with our complex sexual lives, then we might be more tolerant of others as they grapple with theirs.

In addition, our lives are too fast paced and too focused on productivity. A sensuous life requires that one slow down, but we’re not willing to do that, because we tend to justify our existence through work. And look at the places where we work. Go to the fanciest office buildings in New York City. They are not sensuous. You walk into the lobby and find high ceilings, marble walls, no place to sit, no place for the body. And now, with so many of us working in front of computer screens all day, we don’t even look at each other.
We are culturally induced to find meaning in acquiring new and better gadgets and machines. As a result, we’re making our living environments more efficient and less beautiful. So many of the beautiful old buildings are being torn down. I travel a lot on book tours — Atlanta, Denver, Chicago — and as soon as I get into town, people say, “Please come help us fight to save this great old building.” All this beauty is being destroyed in favor of homogeneous boxes; you can’t even tell one building from the next. We don’t realize that, in destroying old buildings, we are also destroying our sexuality.

Zeiger: A friend of mine who teaches at a girls prep school worries about how sexualized her thirteen-year-old students are, with their revealing halter tops and tight pants. Yet they don’t know the first thing about sex. She tells me that they are unabashedly engaging in oral sex and, like Bill Clinton, saying that it’s not sex. Their bodies have become commodities that they exchange. It’s scary.

Moore: It is scary. I don’t want to reduce sexual behavior to simple explanations, but here is one thought that might speak to what you’ve described: We have created a society with many spirited entertainments but few deep pleasures. For most, work is not a pleasure, family pleasures seem to have been lost, and beauty has given way to function and profit. In this wasteland — just visit any small town and walk the strip of fast-food restaurants and gas stations — sex becomes exaggerated and problematic. It takes the place of all those other pleasures.

We don’t have the daily physical activity that people in another time had in the normal course of their lives, so sex is now our primary avenue to the body. In what other arena can those kids you describe explore their bodies and get away from the flatness of daily life? And what cultural images do they have to help them deepen their sexuality: Movies full of symptomatic sexuality? Television programs about the extremes of sexual behavior? Songs that take sex to its painful limits?

Zeiger: You emphasize the importance of marriage, family, and kids as the arena in which we work out our lives.

Moore: It seems to me that marriage is a holy state. It’s never easy, but it polishes away our narcissism and deepens our capacity to love. Living with and caring for children does the same. Children are very demanding, but they give us remarkable perspectives on all aspects of life.

That is not to say, however, that the single, childless life is soulless. I’ve been a celibate monk, I’ve been single, I’ve been married, and I’ve gone through divorce. I’m a father and a stepfather. All these ways of life are full of soul. I focus particularly on marriage because marital sex is often felt to be limited and not as exciting as nonmarital sex. To me, sex in marriage can be particularly intense, valuable, and satisfying because it can bring the whole of life together, whereas, when engaging in sex with a relative stranger, one tends to separate one’s heart and emotions from the lovemaking. It is in long-term relationships — marriage and family and children — that we really work out our lives.
 *************

Really, I guess all I want to say is that what I hope for my daughters as they grow into sexual beings is that they are aware that our culture will try to offer them a very shallow version of sexuality.

I want to tell them that the only way to find liberation from this kind of sexuality (or any other mistreatment or lie) is to realize that being a victim doesn't have to be the end of your story. You are powerful even in your victimhood when you let yourself find the goodness that will also be around you.

Every human being will be hurt by, exploitation is real. So is your power. You'll know that power when you feel the goodness that comes from giving to yourself and others. Today I showed you an example of this in a video of women working hard to give to themselves and others in sports or exercise. I told you that what I saw in that example is that giving when it would be easier to quit is always painful, but it is our only power. 

Someday when you're older I will show you this example too.